SAUL ESLAKE

Economist

SAUL ESLAKE

‘Welcome to my website …
I’m an independent economist, speaker, company director
and Vice-Chancellor’s Fellow at the University of Tasmania’

Labor’s negative gearing aims echo Coalition housing changes


Housing, Publications, Taxation | 23rd March 2016

Saul Eslake | The New Daily | 23rd March 2016

Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has been vocal in decrying the Labor Opposition’s plans to restrict negative gearing to investors buying new properties, claiming it will lead to a crash in the price of existing housing.

But the evidence is against this hypothesis. Over the last five years, every state and territory government across Australia (mostly Coalition governments) has abolished the grants formerly made to first-time buyers of established dwellings, and increased (in most cases doubled) the grants for first-time buyers of new dwellings without noticeable damage to the market.

• Saul Eslake: Negative gearing proponents’ claims don’t stack up
• Interest rates are on the move – you just can’t see it yet
• Home brand snobbery is costing you money
• All signs points to a post-election ‘borrowing boom’

Two other important policy changes implemented in the past two years by the Abbott and Turnbull governments have, taken together, had the objective of dampening investor demand for established housing and deflecting buyers towards new housing.

The first of these is the tightening of Foreign Investment Review Board (FIRB) regulation of foreign investment in housing.

Abbott and Hockey restricted foreign investment. Photo:AAP
Abbott and Hockey restricted foreign investment. Photo: AAP
It was initiated by former Treasurer Joe Hockey after recommendations from a Parliamentary committee chaired by now Assistant Treasurer, Kelly O’Dwyer.

These changes significantly increased the penalties for foreigners acquiring established properties without FIRB approval.

Crackdown on foreign housing investment

They also imposed greater reporting requirements on real estate agents selling properties to foreign investors and boosted the resources available to FIRB to monitor compliance.

Foreigners actually account for a very small proportion of the demand for established dwellings. In 2013-14, the latest year for which figures are available, FIRB-approved foreign purchases of established dwellings totalled $7.2 billion.

Even if, for the sake of the argument, one assumes that foreigners actually acquired twice this amount, or $14.4 billion, of established property in 2013-14, the figure pales into insignificance against the $116 billion lent to Australian investors for the purchase of established properties in 2013-14 and the $108 billion lent to Australian owner-occupiers for the same purpose.

By contrast, FIRB approved $27.6 billion in foreign purchases of new residential properties in 2013-14. That’s almost four times the amount lent to Australian investors in new residential property in the same year and close to the $32 billion lent to Australian owner-occupiers for the purchase or construction of new homes.

In other words, making an educated guess about the amount of equity provided by Australian investors in new housing, foreign investors are doing around three times as much as Australian investors to add to the supply of housing.

Encouraging new housing investors

Rightly, the Abbott and Turnbull governments have sought to dampen foreign demand for existing housing – even at the risk of reducing the price that Australian sellers of existing housing might receive for their properties – whilst encouraging foreigners to buy new housing.

Similarly, last year the Australian Prudential Regulatory Authority (APRA), with at least the tacit approval of both the Abbott and Turnbull governments, directed the banks to tighten lending criteria for property investors. Once again, the effect of these changes has been to dampen the demand for housing from investors (93 per cent of whom purchase established housing).

Foreign money is building Aussie homes. Photo:AAP
Foreign money is building new Aussie homes. Photo: AAP
Since the end of last year, lending to property investors has fallen by 15 per cent – while lending to owner-occupiers has risen by eight per cent.

Bob’s your uncle

Have all these changes ‘smashed’ the housing market? No, they haven’t. To be sure, the rate of escalation of existing property prices has slowed – but that’s a good thing!

As a result, would-be owner-occupiers have been more successful in buying homes. And there have been no across-the-board or sustained falls in property prices.

Labor’s negative gearing policy is designed to achieve exactly the same objectives as these Coalition-approved changes to regulations governing foreign purchases of established property and the lending practices of Australian banks.

Those changes have been good for the Australian property market, and especially for would-be homebuyers: and so would the changes to negative gearing proposed by Labor.

Saul Eslake is a leading Australian economist. He worked as the Chief Economist at the ANZ for 14 years and has worked at Bank of America-Merrill Lynch. Between 2009 and 2011, he was the Director of the Productivity Growth Program at the Grattan Institute. Visit his official website here.

WEEKLY CHART PACK


Each weekend since mid-April 2020 I’ve been preparing, updating and distributing a weekly Coronavirus Impact Chart Pack to people in Australia and overseas. Running to over 100 pages it includes:

  • charts tracking the spread of Covid-19, globally and in Australia, and government responses to it;
  • the impact on the global economy and major individual economies such as China, Japan, other Asian economies, the US and Europe;
  • financial and commodities markets;
  • multiple aspects of the Australian economy, including state-level comparisons, and the policy responses of the Australian and state or territory governments, and the Reserve Bank of Australia; and
  • similar, though smaller coverage of the New Zealand economy.

The Coronavirus Impact Chart Pack will be updated every Saturday afternoon, Australian time, for as long as it remains topical. It will be accessible to subscribers of the Premium Access package.

If and when Covid-19 ceases to be front and centre of attention (as it is now) – whenever that might be – I will continue to prepare a Weekly Chart Pack, but with a focus on whatever replaces the virus as the issue du jour.

ECONOMIC IMPACT OF THE CORONAVIRUS PANDEMIC
24th July 2021


CORONAVIRUS IMPACT CHART PACK 2021-07-24

"I see a lot of chart packs in my line of work, but yours is about the best I have seen. It is amazingly comprehensive, covering far more of the world than any individual is entitled to cover, the charts are clear and easy to understand and they drill down into each topic in a very satisfying way. So well done, Saul."

Alan Kohler, ABC finance presenter, founder of Eureka Report


"A timely and comprehensive summary from one of Australia's best economists."

Adam Creighton, Economics Editor for The Australian


“I continue to find you thinking invaluable - this year to my ritual weekend reading of the economist I have happily added ‘Saul’s latest’.”

Rufus Black, former Managing Partner of McKinsey’s, and currently Vice-Chancellor of the University of Tasmania


“Your chart pack is amazing - and thanks for offering to add me to the mailing list, that would be great to be included. Everything you could want to know is there - and the way the data are organised and presented to tell the stories makes it so easy to follow.”

Prof Jeff Borland, Truby Williams Professor of Economics, The University of Melbourne, Website


“An excellent summary. Although I take a great interest in what’s happening with COVID-19 day by day In Australia and Internationally, I always find your weekly summary a very interesting review of the past week.”

retired former Chief Executive Officer of a District Hospital Service in New South Wales


WEEKLY CHART PACK

EVENTS

Saul Eslake online presentation


“You are the best economic thinker in the country hands down”

Sheryle Bagwell, recently retired Senior Business Correspondent (and sometime Executive Producer),
ABC Radio National Breakfast


"I see a lot of chart packs in my line of work, but yours is about the best I have seen. It is amazingly comprehensive, covering far more of the world than any individual is entitled to cover, the charts are clear and easy to understand and they drill down into each topic in a very satisfying way.
So well done, Saul."

Alan Kohler, ABC finance presenter, founder of Eureka Report


“I continue to find you thinking invaluable - this year to my ritual weekend reading of the economist I have happily added ‘Saul’s latest’.”

Rufus Black, former Managing Partner of McKinsey’s, and currently Vice-Chancellor of the University of Tasmania


“Your chart pack is amazing - and thanks for offering to add me to the mailing list, that would be great to be included. Everything you could want to know is there - and the way the data are organised and presented to tell the stories makes it so easy to follow.”

Prof Jeff Borland, Truby Williams Professor of Economics, The University of Melbourne, Website


“An excellent summary. Although I take a great interest in what’s happening with COVID-19 day by day In Australia and Internationally, I always find your weekly summary a very interesting review of the past week.”

retired former Chief Executive Officer of a District Hospital Service in New South Wales


“Just want to congratulate you Saul on the unbelievably good set of slides you just presented, possibly the best I have ever seen. You have set the bar very high.”

Dr Joe Flood, Adjunct Fellow, RMIT University, Pandemicia


“Thank you very much for your excellent presentation for the Economic Society today. It is always a great pleasure to hear your eloquent, up-to-date and comprehensive talks.”

Andrew Trembath, economist, Victorian and Australian Government agencies


online events @ saul-eslake.com


Quantitative Easing & Modern Monetary Policy

Some commentators seem to think that ‘QE’ is simply a variant of, or a step along the road to, something called ‘Modern Monetary Theory’ or ‘MMT’.  It isn’t: and so in the second part of this series Saul explains what MMT is (and isn’t).

JULY

29th

What is ‘QE’, and how does it work?

5:00 PM Australian Eastern Standard Time
3:00 PM Hong Kong | 2:00 PM Jakarta | 9:00 AM Central European | 8:00 AM London
Cost: FREE ~ Includes access to Saul's presentation slides and video

In this webinar Saul will explain exactly what ‘QE’ is, how its done, why central banks are doing it, what its intended and unintended effects are, and how long central banks might keep doing it for.

Register NOW

AUG

TBC

Modern Monetary Theory

5:00 PM Australian Eastern Standard Time
3:00 PM Hong Kong | 2:00 PM Jakarta | 9:00 AM Central European | 8:00 AM London
Cost: $50.00 AUD ~ Includes access to Saul's presentation slides and video

In this webinar Saul will explain what MMT is (and what it isn’t), what the historical record shows about how it might work in practice, and what some of the results might be if it were implemented in current circumstances.

Register NOW


Request Speaking Engagement

WHAT'S NEW

Most Recent Articles, Talks and Presentations


Corona Virus Impact Chart Pack 2021-07-24

Chart Pack | 24th July 2021

Pop goes the rental
Topics | 26th July 2021

How is the immigration pause affecting Australia’s economy?
Australian Society and Politics, Covid-19 Video, Economic Policies, The Australian Economy | 22nd July 2021

The Future of Super
Economic Policies, The Australian Economy | 16th July 2021

The Post-Pandemic Economy
The Australian Economy | 13th July 2021

Peripheral Asia
Asian Economies | 7th July 2021

Video & Presentation Slides: Australia’s ‘new protectionism’
Australia's New Protectionism, Australian Society and Politics, Economic Policies, The Australian Economy | 25th June 2021

Saul talks to Alan Kohler about ‘Australia’s New Protectionism’
Australian Society and Politics, Covid-19 Video, News | 23rd June 2021

Stanley
Tasmania | 21st June 2021

The cost of appeasing Western Australia
Australian Society and Politics, Economic Policies, Tasmania | 20th June 2021

Australia’s race against the virus
Australian Society and Politics, Covid-19 Video, News | 18th June 2021

Hiding behind the ‘health advice’
Australian Society and Politics, Publications | 14th June 2021

Tasmania’s fiscal position
Tasmania | 14th June 2021

Failure, Success, Risk and Luck: Some Personal Reflections
Australian Society and Politics | 10th June 2021

How Victoria became one of Australia’s ‘poorer’ states over the past 10 years
Publications, The Australian Economy | 4th June 2021

Where does the ‘excess US stimulus’ show up – in higher inflation or a bigger current account deficit
Economic Policies, The Global Economy | 3rd June 2021

Victorians have become poorer than residents all other states and territories except one
Economic Policies, News, The Australian Economy | 2nd June 2021

Will the property market stay this ‘hot’?
Economic Policies, News, The Australian Economy | 2nd June 2021

Victoria’s economic performance over the past decade
Economic Policies, News, Publications, The Australian Economy | 31st May 2021

VIDEO

Recent Presentations


The Impact of Covid-19 series

These videos are available to audience of Saul’s presentations as soon as they are uploaded and will be available to public one month after the presentation date.

See more


TESTIMONIALS

What Others Say


“You are one of the best at what you do in the world”
Gail Fosler, Chief Economist, The Conference Board, New York, December 2002

“I have never known an economist to have such a knowledge of world economic facts and to be able to bring to bear so much information in answering a question without notice”
Charles Goode, Chairman, ANZ Bank, July 2009

“Saul Eslake is … a highly regarded independent economist with the highest degree of integrity"
John Durie, Columnist, The Australian, July 2009

“… one of the few people in this world who can have so many oranges up in the air at the same time but still manage to catch them"
Andrew Clark, journalist, Australian Financial Review, November 2008

Read more

LINKS

Useful Links